top of page
Image by Aaron Burden

Articles

AI legal advice: when you should call a lawyer

Apr 4, 2022
3 min read

Updated: Oct 6


Two women talk across a speckled table with paper, pens, and glasses, gesturing in a bright  meeting room, trying to problem solve.

More people now turn to AI for legal advice before they speak to anyone else. That's understandable as it is often free, it's instant, and it can be genuinely useful for understanding a term in a contract or getting a general sense of how something works.


It also means more people are calling us later, after they've signed the agreement, sent the email, or let a deadline pass because a chatbot made the problem sound simpler than it was. By then, we're often unravelling a problem that didn't need to exist, and that usually costs far more in legal fees than getting advice at the start.


So our answer to "when should I call a lawyer?" is the same as it has always been, only more important now: as early as possible.


What AI does well


AI is good at explaining general principles and summarising information. It cannot exercise judgment about your particular situation, as it is always more nuanced. Legal problems are rarely just legal. They involve people, relationships, history and risk, and the right answer usually depends on things a chatbot never asks about.


The right lens for the problem - what AI legal advice cannot do


An AI tool cannot:


  • read the dynamics between you and the other party, or tell when a firm letter will help and when it will make things worse;

  • weigh what matters most to you, whether that's money, speed, privacy, or preserving a family or business relationship;

  • spot the issue you didn't think to mention, which is often the one that matters most;

  • build rapport with the solicitor on the other side to solve problems constructively;

  • keep sensitive information confidential and shielded from discovery requests from your opponent; or

  • take responsibility for its advice, or stand beside you if things go wrong.


It also tends to answer confidently, whether or not it's right, and it may not reflect the law as it applies in Western Australia today.


A good lawyer looks at the whole picture. They draw on years of experience and insight to look not only at the documents in front of you, but also the people involved, the commercial realities, and where things are likely to go next. Often the most valuable advice isn't about the law at all. It's knowing which battles are worth fighting and which conversations to have before anything is put in writing. That kind of judgment is most useful if obtained early, before positions harden and options close.


When to pick up the phone


It's worth speaking to us:

  • before you sign a commercial contract, lease or partnership agreement

  • when you're buying or selling a business or property

  • when you're making or updating a will, or a family member's estate is in question

  • when you've received a demand letter, claim or notice

  • when a company you own, run or are owed money by is in financial difficulty

  • when you join the board of a charity or not-for-profit


How we can help


M 6:8 Legal advises individuals, businesses and community organisations on commercial contracts, wills and estates, business sales and purchases, property, insolvency, and charity and not-for-profit governance. Many of the matters we see are personal and sensitive, and we handle them with care as well as rigour.


Do use AI to get your bearings. Then call our lawyers in Myaree on +61 8 9316 8363 before you act on what it tells you. Timely advice now is better than fixing a problem later.


This article is for general information only. It is not legal advice.

 
 
 

Comments


A mug sitting on a wooden table. The decorative writing on the mug says 'begin'.

We're here to help, get in touch today.

bottom of page